Reposted from the Scotland trip planning thread, looking for Dundee/Carnoustie/Angus/Tayside/Fife folks specifically…
"I am planning a Scotland trip next summer as a reward for myself: I’m in grad school right now, and I’ve had a lot of tough experiences the last few years, and so Scotland is a nice carrot to get me through the finish line.
Because things have been so hard, and because I’m me, my plan right now is as follows:
** Base myself in the Dundee/Carnoustie region - lots of good, reasonably-priced golf. Fewer Bag Tag Barrys. Easy to get to courses in the area via bus or train (I’m not renting a car). Affordable prices - I’m on a modest budget. I also like that the walks on those courses are more reasonable because of the terrain around Dundee/Carnoustie. I’ve got a bad back and would hate to have it ruin my first trip over to Scotland.*
** Buy a distance membership and season ticket at a course and use it as my base. This saves money and allows me to immerse myself in links golf by experiencing one course via multiple plays, rather than playing a ton of places once or twice and not really knowing any of them. My options were Montrose, Panmure, Arbroath, and Monifieth. Ultimately, I chose Monifieth because of location, the vibe of the club (I did a ton of research, made calls, sent emails), two courses where their shorter course is challenging and quirky as hell, and the price. Plus, I’ll have a club to go back to and maintain my membership (at least the club membership, not the season ticket on the years I don’t return) for years as I continue to make trips back, and one day bring my son when he’s old enough.*
** Then play a few reasonably priced highlights in the area: my list right now is Panmure, Arbroath, Montrose, and Carnoustie Burnside. I’ll probably pick two or three of those.*
** I’m also going to take the train over to St. Andrews on a Sunday, then play one of the ‘other’ courses - thinking it’s The Eden for me. My plan is to walk The Old Course either before or after.*
With flights, shipping my clubs, staying in an Air BnB in Monifieth, fees at the other clubs (most will be reduced by half because of the ‘Carnoustie Country’ discount I’ll get as a member of Monifieth), trains/taxis/busses, and food and incidentals - this will be a very REASONABLY priced trip where I’ll truly experience a town, a different culture, a different club, a different style of golf, and people - rather than ferrying around the country by car or with a group and playing a bunch of places once. I’m not knocking those ‘Once in a Lifetime’ trips, but I plan on going back; that was another reason for joining a club.
I realize for some of you, this may seem too low-key. I don’t worry about FOMO; I want something more immersive and natural than the typical American golf tourist’s experience.
I have a few questions for my Scotish/UK Refugians:
*1. What are some food/sights/excursion ideas between Dundee and Montrose? What are the places to eat and see that I can’t miss? *
2. What have folks’ experiences been taking their clubs on trains and buses in Scotland?
3. In St. Andrews on Sunday…is there a good spot to ‘stash’ my clubs while I’m walking the Old Course while it’s closed, or should I just do the Sunday trip as a separate side jaunt and not try to play The Eden the same day?
4. Any UK folks want to grab a pint? A bite? A round in Carnoustie Country (Monifieth, Panmure, Carnoustie Burnside, Arbroath, Montrose) next August? Your boy’ll be there - rocketing seeds all over the place and getting up and down from impossible situations lol