Been a little frustrated lately having songs stuck in my head from local bands from when I was in highschool and lost the original CD’s I bought at their shows but their music doesn’t exist online anymore because they were too small.
Radiolab just did a 5 part series on the casette tape. The last episoe (Mixtake: Help?) has a section where they go through old casette mixtapes of music that past lovers had given them. Even after quite some time you can hear how emotional they make people. I think you’re right that a Spotify playlist just aint the same.
A real mix tape…even a mixed (burned) CD took a lot more time to create. It actually showed dedication. Especially if you were recording songs from an actual radio station.