OATW Match Play - 2025 Second Round Underway?

Met @joecline41 Friday evening for a balmy Battle of the Joes at Seneca, one of our Metropark gems in Cleveland. We played Furnace/Chippewa for those in the know, and @the_wizard and his wife served as markers.

That last piece was a subtle, and as far as I know unintentional, pro move by Joe C. You see, Waldo’s wife and I worked together for a handful of years, and we spent much of the pre-match and opening holes catching up. To say I wasn’t focused would be an understatement, and you need look no further than my triple on 1 for evidence. I may have pulled a fairway Saddam. Woof.

Joe C came out firing, quickly jumping out to a two hole lead through two holes played. With the 95°-but-feels-like-102° forcing sweat out of my fingernails, I knew I had to lock in. Especially since Joe C’s game appeared to be metronome-consistent.

In true Pop City fashion, what better time than the first of 6 holes I’d pop on: the par 5 third? I took it with a 5 for 4 and the match was truly on.

The front was a back and forth affair, with just three holes halved. We went to the back with Joe C one up and both of us playing steady, bogey-adjacent golf.

The back got off to a tough start for Joe C, though, with an errant tee shot turned lost ball that an angry gaggle of geese may or may not have compounded. I made a relatively comfy par and we were back to all square.

That was the first of a three hole stretch of won holes for me which culminated in a birdie-for-eagle at the 555 yard par 5 12th. I was two up as we headed to the final third.

At this point, I should remind you that it was unbearably hot. There were good shots and bad shots. I know I had found my driver around 11, and Joe C’s was hot and cold. But I honestly don’t remember very many specific shots, epic saves, or massive mistakes. They definitely happened, but I can’t recall them. I do remember heat. Thick, steam-rushing-from-an-opened-oven, dog-days-of-summer heat.

And I remember an oasis in the grassy desert. Truly exemplifying the TC Way, Joe C had a family-sized cooler of waters and he was graciously sharing. I would’ve melted if not for that cooler and those waters. Joe C is a first class dude.

But we have a match to finish. Bogey golf was played by each of us over holes 13, 14, and 15, and we halved each of the holes. We went to 16 with Joe C desperately needing to take a hole, being down two with three to play.

7 on Chippewa is a fairly easy par 4 playing 373 from our tees. Water looms right and, weary of an OB ball in such an important spot, each of us sent tee shots left of the fairway. I sent my approach over the green. Joe C left his short. And then he left a second short. I ended up winning the hole with a 5 following a chip and two putt, Joe C’s otherwise brutally consistent short game failing him in this pivotal moment. And there the match ended, a 3&2 victory for Joe A’s everywhere.

Really grateful for Joe C’s company and hospitality. No surprise he spent a cup of coffee in that industry. I hope Pounders was thoroughly air conditioned and the col beers were just a smidge above freezing.

And really great catching up with Waldo and his missus. Hoping to see y’all out there again soon.

5 Likes

They were indeed a welcome end to the evening. Great time meeting Joe A. and Mrs. @the_wizard.

I don’t remember a round where I felt very much like I had it and then all of a sudden…I did not have it. I’m usually a slow starter then find my groove near the turn. It’s comforting knowing it may not have mattered if I kept hitting it well because Joe A. flipped the switch on the back and played a lights out second 9. A very well-earned win.

6 Likes

This will not be nearly as detailed as some of the recent posts of others’ matches, so apologies as I begin.
On Thursday @JDR9 was gracious enough to host our round of 32 match at Brookside Golf and Country Club. Was it a smart move to play the guy who has worked on and around those greens for the last 11 years? Probably not. Would I ever turn down a chance to play there? Absolutely not.
We seesawed back and forth throughout the match, with each of us holding 2 up leads at different points, with only 2 holes being won with worse than par (maybe there were a couple of concessions, but I’m telling the story.)
Josh held a 2 up lead walking off 15 after I gacked an uphill 3 footer (not a shocker to anyone who has ever played with me, met me, or driven within 500 feet of a golf course,) but wins on 16 and 17 got the match back to square on the 18th tee. I hit my best drive of the day to the center of the fairway while Josh’s found the fairway bunker. His approach got out of the bunker but was short of the green, and I hit a shot to about 20 feet past the flag. I was able to cozy my birdie putt to gimme distance, then held my breath as his par putt slid by underneath the hole to give me the victory 1 up.
Once again, a thousand thanks to @JDR9 for the invite and a great match but an even better experience. On to the round of 16!

8 Likes

Just got home from an eventful round at Manakiki facing off vs @CorneliousPoon. Pop city was once again in full effect as I was yet again getting 21 strokes. Sometimes being a high handicapper has its advantages.

We started off the round a little slow, both making doubles and I took a 1 up lead thanks to my stroke on the hole. Dan got it right back to all square after 2. He really got in the groove from there and didn’t make worse than bogey the rest of the round. However, I used my strokes to my advantage and had it all square coming to 8, which was one of my 2-stroke holes.

I really struggled off the tee at times today (including hitting two in the woods on 6 before finally keeping something in play and wasting a 2 pop hole with a 10 - ouch), but was able to find the fairway on 8. I then chunked my approach into the bunker and had a 50+ yard bunker shot that I thinned to the back right of the green. I proceeded to chip it only to have it run through the green and into the rough off the front left of the green. Dan made a cozy par, but I managed to chip in for 5-for-3 and take a 1 up lead. We both made par on 9, and that put me 2 up at the turn. It was about the 9th hole (I think) where it started to rain and by 10 it was pouring. It helped cool down what had started as a hot morning, even though we teed off before 6:30am.

10 was the last of my 2-stroke holes. I managed to take the hole using my double pops for a 3 up lead. I then pushed the next couple holes with bogey net pars before blowing up with a 9 on 13. I was now 2 up. At that point Dan was gaining momentum with par or better for several straight holes.

On 14 he pulled his tee shot left while I found the the fairway, but then he hit his approach just off the back of the green while I proceeded to chunk my wedge on approach and then leave my pitch just short of the green. The tides appeared to be turning and it seemed like Dan was going to get it back to 1 up with 4 to play. Unfortunately for Dan (but luckily for me) I ended up making a putt from off the green for a par net birdie and took it back to 3 up. It was definitely a big momentum swing back in my favor.

We came to 15 and had a back pin. I wasn’t feeling super confident. I have no length to my game, don’t hit long irons well, and had already chunked tee shots on multiple par 3s. Somehow I managed to hit a 5 iron to maybe 12-15 feet? Dan pulled his tee shot a little left, but got a great kick and the ball ended up just off the back of the green. We both made easy pars, but I finished off the match 4 and 3 thanks to my stroke.

I had a lovely morning walking Manakiki with Dan even with the heat and then the rain. He was a real pleasure to play with. It’s awesome how I have yet to find someone in this match play set up that I haven’t enjoyed playing with.

I would also like to take this opportunity to thank the person behind the creation of the handicap system, as I wouldn’t be in this position without the hefty amount of strokes I received.

Next up I’ve got @cussingmussel in my crosshairs. We are very familiar with each other’s game as we play together basically weekly. He’s coming off the two best rounds of his life, so I’m in for a real tough match. We just so happen to be going on a trip to Grand Rapids this weekend to play some golf, so we will be playing our quarterfinal match at Mines Golf Club.

7 Likes

Really good match, even better company. Think I’m gonna trademark “The Paula Abdul” for a straight up match. Thank you for leaving out me yacking on myself on 17. Good luck to everyone left in the bracket

7 Likes

“I visited pip city and all I got was a lousy ass wooping”

@spicychimis was a gentleman and a scholar while he slowly stole my soul. Despite a slow start I played a really solid round from 5-18. My approach going in was to par him to death and simply let him make enough mistakes to earn me the win. I executed on my half of the bargain but steve did not. He was relentless all day. On multiple occasions I was sure I had a hole won only for him to chip in or sink a putt from off the green. His tee ball on 15 was one of the best shots I’ve ever seen on that hole and a fitting way to end the match. Despite the result it was a great walk from start to finish!

5 Likes

Have you made contact with @Twowaymiss or @PlumbBobMillionaire yet by chance? That’s our last first round matchup that needs to be completed.

We’re making pretty good progress overall with the bracket which I’m very excited about. We already have two quarter-final match ups figured out and one of them scheduled. With the other side of the SW bracket quarter scheduled to be figured out by the end of this week.

I have not but I can reach out this week.

1 Like

Twoway and I are set to play this upcoming Monday. The winner will be able to play the next round relatively quick

1 Like

@golf4miami and I finally managed to get our Round of 16 match in today, despite thunderstorms upon arrival and an hour delay. Also had to walk because of the rain.

We sort of randomly ended up at Bella Vista Golf Club - needed a course with roughly the same distance from Indianapolis and Detroit. Could not have found a better course- gorgeous, in great shape, a certified Audubon Cooperative Sanctuary and $30 to walk ($45 to ride). Hidden gem in Michigan!

The course may have been the best golf thing today. Ryan and I have now played three times this season, with him beating me 2&1 and 1 up. Playing the Blues (ended up being the tips) I got 9 strokes today. The handicap system certainly works for us, as the final score today was also 1 up.

We only tied 3 of the first 8 stroke holes with both of us winning the other stroke holes straight out. Heading in to hole 18, we had finished 7 holes All Square, 8 holes 1 up and just two ending with a 2 up score. Needless to stay, we approached 18 tee All Square.

Ryan had offhandedly mentioned at the beginning of the round that he would not want to be playing 18 All Square because I popped there. He killed a drive down the middle of the fairway- I hit one much shorter (only 292 yards) and just through the fairway. Had 114 in to the pin and hit it 29 feet short. Ryan also hit the green (long) with his second shot. I didn’t hit my first putt well and left myself about 8 feet for par. Ryan’s birdie putt was a little short from his side as well so when I made my putt the match was over.

Can’t say enough how nice this course was, if not easy, and what fun it was to play Ryan, all three times. I look forward to my next match, whomever it is just let me know.

199 yard par 3 #2

Probably the most tight chute (of several). You can just about see the beginning of the fairway, as this hole plays as a 365 yard dogleg right from these tees.

7 Likes

Those visuals off the tee are pretty insane. Imagine someone from Florida or Texas seeing that. Yeesh!

3 Likes

We now go to @OffTheDole for comment.

2 Likes

I just want to say that every single time I’ve played @auribe14 it’s been a blast and an interesting experience both course wise and competition wise. We’ve had two matches where we were going back and forth trading blows (and poor shots) and one where he got out to a solid lead and I came storming back. Tough to play the same guy three times in a calendar year and expect to win all three times.

Bummed I cannot take my defense of the trophy further, but looking forward to see who comes out victorious this year!

8 Likes

@robot_mrvn and I had our match yesterday at SCC.

Like all rounds at SCC, it started out with a quick punch in the mouth on 1. Wes put up a totally reasonably bogey, but a mediocre drive and much better approach allowed me to steal the hole with a par, net birdie, going one up. From there, pop city was in full effect and a combination of poor drives with very sensible plotting my way around had me going (net) -1 on the front and making the turn with a 4 up lead, bogey and paring Wes to death.

That is where I started to fall back to my high handicap ways. The pops really helped my double, double, bogey, triple run weather the storm a little. I was able to close Wes out with a net par on 14 with a 5 & 4 win. That couldn’t have come soon enough. Somehow I found my driver at the expense of everything else from there on out leading to a 9 shot differential between my front and back.

As always with Refuge play, Wes was a great to play with and I am sure we will face off again in future events.

@auribe14. Looks we are up next.

5 Likes

Ok. Give me an idea when you’re available and where you want to play.

1 Like

Thanks Chad for the great round!

3 Likes

@cussingmussel and I got out for our match this past Saturday at Mines Golf Club in Grand Rapids with @Dangelor along as our local Sherpa. Want to start off by saying we couldn’t have asked for a better local guide. Ryan was an awesome hang, had great insight into playing the course for us two first timers, and, oh yeah, he golfed the shit out of his ball too. I felt bad at times for the pillow fight he had to witness from most of the match.

On to the match. It was a battle to be the mayor of Pop City and I was getting 6 strokes. Fortunately, I made good use of most of them. I got out to a quick lead, going 2 up after 2 thanks to my bogey net par on the second hole. I was still 2 up heading into back to back par 3s with 7 and 8. On 7 I hit a solid shot only for Joe to answer with a solid shot of his own, leaving it just outside of my ball. He steps up and drains the putt for birdie, beating out my comfy par to get it back down to 1 up. I think we would both like to forget the 8th hole where we each ended up with multiple shots to get out of our respective bunkers. Joe sucked less than I did and takes the match to all square. I took advantage of another bunker issue on 9 to make the turn at 1 up.

Joe got the match back to all square with a solid par on 11, which is how it stayed until I won 15 and 16 to get him dormie on 17. With the pressure on, Joe won 17 to take the match to 18. Unfortunately for @cussingmussel, some of the problems getting off the tee he had been fighting this round reared their ugly head on 18 and I was able to take the hole despite a shitty drive, a chunked iron, and a poor 3 putt.

The match really ended with a whimper. Definitely wasn’t the best either of us have played, but I’ll take a win however I can get it. And it was good pay back for getting my ass kicked in the match we played at Pilgrim’s the day before.

Looking forward to my next match. Hopefully I can continue my trend of just frustrating opponents with my never ending stream of pops.

5 Likes

It was my pleasure fellas, hopefully next time you come up we have a little less rain before hand! Had a blast watching Joe drain those long putts and Steve step up when he needed to!

3 Likes

We got it in thanks to some planes, trains and automobiles. I redeemed last years knockout round defeat (brought to you by Whoop©️) and defeated @Twowaymiss 4&3 at Darby Creek.

Our match featured an abundant cornucopia of Ohio public golf cliches: a fully booked tee sheet on a fucking Monday, an anxious/overly-aggressive starter with a broken watch and inspiring golf played among friends. @SRS_One provided the marker duties.

Some shoutouts…

  1. Andrew’s wife for let him come basically straight to the golf course from the airport after a handful of days at an undisclosed location with a new baby. GOAT shit, right there.
  2. Scott hit a shot from 170+ which landed on a rake, making the coolest sound I’ve heard on a golf course in YEARS. The ball ended up on the green via the glorified gardening tool. The “SICK!” call from that echoed through the Darby Creek trees.
  3. Played in like 3:40 thanks to a good old fashioned “play through at the turn” after waiting on every shot most of the first nine.

@wreckhockey and I are up next, in what I believe will be one of the vibe-y matches in recent memory

10 Likes

@jack67 and myself have got our match scheduled for this Friday, 7/5 at 8:30 at CCC. I’ve got the other two spots on the tee sheet blocked if anyone would like to join for their match, or just tag along as a spotter/Hitter Blanco.

2 Likes