Nantz Pod

Still listening, but I find it pretty telling that Nantz felt the need to vociferously defend the telecast, not just in response to questions but also unprompted, for over 30 minutes, and was ready for more if necessary. Also quite notable that he came prepared with times for each segment between commercials for the telecast this weekend.

There was a segment that was only 1:32 between commercials, which he said was probably around the time they were entering the last hour of coverage. I wonder how many tweets about the commercials were made right at that time? Perhaps the balance of commercial time allotment should be altered to avoid the dreaded commercial - one shot - commercial during the peak time of the telecast…

With that said, I’m also not sure CBS got enough respect for working with a 40-50% crew on site, most running around wearing masks, in mid-90s heat. Hope the guy that’s in the hospital is ok.

15 Likes

I thought he was super defensive about the broadcast. It stinks Jimmy, too many commercials. Not your fault but own it.

7 Likes

Had it on in the car this morning and was just parking as he started reeling off the segment times.

I’m surprised Soly hadn’t pressed him (at least not yet) on the non-commercial “stuff” that’s in the telecast. He (Soly) also sounded quite deferential about playing through/eye on the course. While I suppose it’s better than nothing, it’s overall garbage. Yet Soly made it sound like it was some huge improvement. The best (only?) way out of this is soccer- or Augusta-style coverage, with sponsors owning larger live chunks of the broadcast.

5 Likes

I just don’t understand why we can’t get soccer-style coverage. They did a few times during the broadcast last weekend with Charles Schwab. I’m perfectly okay with a near-perpetual graphic in the background for different advertisers. Do it like a golf outing and sell sponsorships per hole.

8 Likes

Nantz = Big Mad. Kudos to Soly for being able to sit through those long-winded responses.

23 Likes

I get the sense from the Twitter replies that this is the overwhelming reaction to the pod, and I felt the same way. Nantz’s default reply to anything resembling criticism was, “C’mon guys, people don’t realize how HARD this all is…”

Then he tries to explain the need for commercials, as if people don’t understand the EXTREMELY complex business model of paying for tv rights, then selling advertising space as your revenue source. We get it Jim. We are your customer, and we’re telling you your product isn’t satisfactory. Rather than trying to convince your customer that the product is actually better than we realize, maybe find a way to deliver what your customers want, or someone else will (ie: the existence of NLU in the first place).

22 Likes

Yeah, I was only able to listen to the first half or so before I arrived at work, but I was kind of surprised how defensive Nantz was. I don’t think he came across very well at all.

I didn’t expect him to be like “yeah, you’re right, our broadcasts suck and last week was nearly unwatchable” but I thought he’d at least go more in the direction of “We definitely get it, and we’re working on it and working with the tour to see what’s possible.”

I don’t blame Soly for not getting super argumentative with him, but even as it relates to Nantz talking about the smaller crew due to COVID, there are still a lot of areas in which that’s not a good enough excuse. To me, that doesn’t really do anything for a lot of instances where they show a lot of one guy but not another. It’s still a camera that’s out there and could be used elsewhere.

Very enlightening episode that I’m glad NLU did, but also not super inspiring if all of CBS feels the same way as Nantz.

6 Likes

I thought Nantz tried to focus mostly on the commercial aspect of the complaints because it is the easiest to justify. Soly did a great job trying to weave in questions and respectably push back. Unfortunately, Nantz didn’t allow him to move the conversation towards the fluff pieces and story telling rather than showing the golf.

1 Like

could only think about this meme when he said his kid’s name was Jameson

18 Likes

Is anyone surprised that Nantz was defensive?

The only thing I’m surprised by is that Nantz agreed to come on the pod.

22 Likes

The long ramble about working with half the crew. - Okay great. We get it. Everyone is doing that type of stuff. We just heard hours of it before the Match 2. It just seemed like diversion to not have to dive into discussing why the most annoying parts of the broadcast have not changed.

Soly mentioning that there is an entire market of younger golf fans who watch tv/streaming series essentially with little to no ads whatsoever and how catering to that could be HUGE in terms of gaining new fans was just met with WELL WE PAY ADS AND SO DO YOU CHRIS!!!

I’m sure the ad deals are astronomical, but is there no way possible to charge for a package to cut down on the 54 minutes of add time at all? Have they even tried? He got so defensive it just seemed like don’t even talk about it. If he came on the pod and told us they are always trying to figure out a way to re-do the ad deals and brainstorming new creative ways around the current model and they were at least trying it would be nice to hear. Instead it was like F off, it’s not changing and we’re not gonna try to change it either.

Their SEC games struggle with the ad money problem as well. There is no reason a football game should be drug out to 4.5 hours with TV timeouts and ad breaks.
The reduced ad version of games that air on SECN or ESPN2 can finish in closer to 2.5.

When Jim Nantz starts punching back at your Urbal Activ ad reads.

66 Likes

Soly should have had ready the percent of the broadcast that goes to commercials versus the percent of the podcast/YouTube videos that go to commercials.

“Jim, I’m glad you brought that up…”

15 Likes

Length of a segment does not necessarily equal more golf shots shown. There’s the rub.
Too many empty stretches of the broadcast where there’s too much traditional sponsor fluff that kills the flow from an audience perspective. That’s where you could push back on Nantz and say that the other networks may take the same amount of commercials per hour but are more innovative in how they can negotiate their sponsorship obligations and maximize the number of shots shown and thus their ability to tell the story of a tournament better than CBS.

Having said that - can’t blame Soly at all for not pushing the issue. Nantz is very well compensated by CBS and is a company lifer, can’t fault the guy for wanting to stick up for his crew who are in a tougher spot than normal due to limited numbers.

23 Likes

Two minutes in and I can already tell by the mood that this is going to be an awkward one.

That said, Nantz is an employee of CBS. Not sure what everyone else would expect from this. And besides, it’s not like Nantz himself is deciding how many commercials there are. He’s the last source of mistakes of CBS golf. He’s the wrong guy to ask about coverage takes, frankly.

10 Likes

You are spot on with the fluff. Gosh, I know Strapped is not live and this is not a one to one comparison, but imagine if we missed “Bring on the pancakes” or the “St. Rappeo” moment because they needed to show a graphic of how many Callaway balls they found total for all the trips, or a BMW miles traveled stat about how much walking and driving the guys did.

3 Likes

Kinda sums up the whole problem, doesn’t it?

3 Likes

That’s how I felt as well. It’s kind of sad that with an hour of Jim Nantz and all the stories he has, you waste 30 minutes having the guy defend against coverage takes. The second half was good and what I would love an entire pod on. Keep the coverage stuff for Lance Barrow or someone else.

3 Likes

Going with your analogy - I trust the NLU guys to come up with a more creative way of presenting their sponsors and keeping them happy than i do CBS. Not an apples to apples comparison by any means.
It’s been made several times on the coverage takes before - but there’s a staleness to golf on CBS and it’s ironic that it took a global pandemic for them to be forced to change up how they cover a tournament and lo and behold it freshened up the broadcasts last week.
Some of it I understand given how much golf they have to show and how they have to move from tournament to tournament, but I prefer NBC and FOX’s coverage to CBS and after the Kostis pod I don’t get the sense that anyone at CBS gives a shit.

2 Likes

Nantz came in hot, but even still I could tell Nantz held back a little bit. He kept make references like “some people say this, maybe not you guys” when he absolutely knows that Soly and NLU had made some of the criticisms he was specifically talking about.

Perhaps the most surprising part of the pod was when Soly actually tried to move away from coverage discussion, but Nantz didn’t let him. He kept wanting to battle.

I don’t blame Soly for not pushing back too hard. It would have made for an awkward podcast, and I think its probably best to not totally burn this bridge. But still, I kind of wish Soly would have brought up how even with the same number of commercials per hour, its pretty apparent that NBC and other networks manage to show more golf shots than CBS.

3 Likes